← Back to Conmac Web DesignsA concept site designed by Conmac Web Designs

Est. 1932

Joey'sPizza Shop, Park Slope

Four generations of the Bellomo family, one recipe, and the same oven fired up every morning.

A slice of pepperoni pizza being pulled from the pie, cheese stretching

Our story

Joey Bellomo opened a six-table pizza shop in Brooklyn in 1932. He knew pizza the way his family made it, but it didn't take him long to learn that Brooklyn had its own taste. So he made a thinner, crispier crust, a sweeter tomato sauce, and a cheese blend that melted just right.

He never rushed it. Dough mixed every morning, sauce made in small batches, mozzarella shredded by hand, and every pie checked by Joey before it left the oven. Factory workers came after their shifts. Families came on Sundays. Kids saved their allowance for a slice after school.

The family never opened a second location, and that was on purpose. Joey believed a neighborhood pizzeria should belong to its neighborhood. Today the fourth generation of Bellomos runs the counter, and the rule is simple: if Joey wouldn't recognize it, it doesn't go on the menu.

Black and white photo of two pizza makers in white aprons in the original shop
The early days on 7th Avenue

Sauce, Sunday batch

San Marzanos, crushed by hand

2 cloves 3 cloves garlic

Basil from the window box

Salt, a little sugar

Low heat. Don't rush it.

The sauce recipe lives in a handwritten notebook in the family kitchen. No measuring cups, no printed card.

Hands pressing out fresh pizza dough on a floured counter Fresh tomatoes, basil, shredded mozzarella, sauce, and a ball of dough A pepperoni pie in front of the fired brick oven

The dough

Made fresh every morning and given time to rise slowly. Mixed and portioned by the family. No frozen dough.

The sauce

The same family recipe since 1932, written in an old notebook with crossed-out measurements and a lot of history.

The cheese

A house blend of mozzarella and aged cheeses. Only three people in the family know the exact ratio.

The oven

Fired every morning and kept up by hand. The family says the oven knows what it's doing, and nobody wants to test that.

Two generations of the Bellomo family smiling in the kitchen today
The Bellomos behind the counter today

The rule behind the counter

Never make a pizza you wouldn't serve to your own family.

Four generations later, the faces have changed. The rule hasn't.

What people say

From neighbors who've been coming for decades and visitors who came back twice in one trip.

A family sharing pizza at a table in the dining room
★★★★★
I've lived in Brooklyn my entire life and eaten more pizza than I'd like to admit. Joey's is the real deal. The crust is thin and crispy without being dry, the sauce actually has flavor, and they don't drown the slice in cheese. Nothing fancy, nothing pretentious. Just an excellent Brooklyn slice. My father brought me here when I was a kid and now I bring my own kids.
Anthony R. Brooklyn
★★★★★
We found Joey's completely by accident while visiting Brooklyn and came back twice before our trip was over. The guy behind the counter told us his great-grandfather opened the place in 1932 and showed us old family photos on the wall. Get the classic cheese slice first. Trust me.
Melissa T. Chicago
★★★★★
Forget the Instagram pizza places with hour-long lines. Joey's is what a New York pizzeria is supposed to be. Hot oven, old booths, guys who remember your order. Crispy underneath, chewy at the edge, perfect amount of sauce. Been coming here for 14 years and they haven't messed with a good thing.
David M. Brooklyn

Catering and private parties

Office lunches, birthdays, game days, family get-togethers. We do trays of pasta, heros, salads, and as many pies as you need, ready for pickup or delivered.

Want the whole shop? Joey's is available for private parties. Call and we'll put together a menu that fits your group and budget.

Call and ask for Tony

(555) 324-7895 Give us a few days' notice for large orders.

Come by

The dining room with brick walls, wooden tables, and family photos The outdoor patio under string lights

Brick walls, old booths, and family photos inside. Patio seating out front when the weather's good.

Where

7th Avenue
Park Slope, Brooklyn, NY

Get directions

Hours

Every day11am to 11pm

Dine in, pickup, and delivery.

Call or follow

(555) 324-7895

@joeyspizzabk

Call Order on DoorDash