Our story
Joey Bellomo opened a six-table pizza shop in Brooklyn in 1932. He knew pizza the way his family made it, but it didn't take him long to learn that Brooklyn had its own taste. So he made a thinner, crispier crust, a sweeter tomato sauce, and a cheese blend that melted just right.
He never rushed it. Dough mixed every morning, sauce made in small batches, mozzarella shredded by hand, and every pie checked by Joey before it left the oven. Factory workers came after their shifts. Families came on Sundays. Kids saved their allowance for a slice after school.
The family never opened a second location, and that was on purpose. Joey believed a neighborhood pizzeria should belong to its neighborhood. Today the fourth generation of Bellomos runs the counter, and the rule is simple: if Joey wouldn't recognize it, it doesn't go on the menu.
Sauce, Sunday batch
San Marzanos, crushed by hand
2 cloves 3 cloves garlic
Basil from the window box
Salt, a little sugar
Low heat. Don't rush it.
The sauce recipe lives in a handwritten notebook in the family kitchen. No measuring cups, no printed card.
The dough
Made fresh every morning and given time to rise slowly. Mixed and portioned by the family. No frozen dough.
The sauce
The same family recipe since 1932, written in an old notebook with crossed-out measurements and a lot of history.
The cheese
A house blend of mozzarella and aged cheeses. Only three people in the family know the exact ratio.
The oven
Fired every morning and kept up by hand. The family says the oven knows what it's doing, and nobody wants to test that.